NEWS PROVIDED BY
Catholic League
Nov. 3, 2026
NEW YORK, Nov. 3, 2026 /Christian Newswire/ — The following is submitted by Bill Donohue, President, Catholic League:
The Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) claims to be a non-partisan research organization. But it is no more “non-partisan” than the ACLU. It is run by left-wing writers and activists and is funded by left-wing foundations (click here for more on this issue).
PRRI recently released its latest American Values Survey. The 2026 edition has the ominous title, “Darkening Mood and Shifting Political Loyalties Ahead of Midterm Elections.” What is so dark about current conditions?
The majority, 71%, say the country is going in the wrong direction. This is up from 62% in 2025. The survey concludes, “Americans have grown more pessimistic about the country’s direction.” That’s a short time span.
The figure for 2024 was 70 percent; it was 77% in 2023; in 2022, it was 74%; and in 2021, it was 74%. In other words, Americans have not been happy about the direction the country has been going for many years, but only when Trump is in office does PRRI raise a red flag.
The need to portray a gloomy report is pure politics. In the 2026 report, Trump is cited 153 times, mostly in negative terms; Biden is not mentioned even once. In 2025, Trump was cited 164 times; Biden was mentioned four times.
There are two segments of American society that PRRI warns about: Trump supporters and Christian nationalists. Both groups are overrepresented by evangelical Protestants. As we shall see, they are the bad guys. But first a word about the survey’s methodology.
Overall, we know that women are more liberal than men, and that the religiously unaffiliated are more liberal than people of faith. Nationwide, 49% of the population is male and 51% is female, but in the survey, 47% are male and 53% are female. Religiously unaffiliated respondents were 24% of the total, which is about the national average, except this category is badly defined.
In their new book, The Death of Religion?: Nones, Others, and the Flourishing of Faith, Bryon R. Johnson and Thomas S. Kidd maintain that the “nones”—the religiously unaffiliated—are more diverse than what many believe. Many of the “nones,” as well as agnostics and atheists, they say, “attend religious services, pray, meditate, believe in God or a higher power, have religious experiences, and believe in heaven, hell, and miracles.”
While Johnson and Kidd have done a great job challenging the conventional wisdom, there are others, including myself, who have made a similar argument. Because this is not breaking news, not to acknowledge this verity is dishonest.
PRRI tells us that “Among Americans who have heard of the term ‘Christian nationalism,’” twice as many have an unfavorable view as have a favorable view. But how many have heard of this term? We are not told. I know why: In 2022 and 2024, 54% in a Pew survey said they never heard of “Christian nationalism.” In 2026, that figure shrank to 40%, but another 15% said they know only “a little.”
That’s not much of a difference. Moreover, respondents are never asked to identify anything about the term, so no one knows whether their perception is accurate to not. Also, people like myself have long criticized the proponents of “Christian nationalism” for their politically drawn analysis.
If there is one subject in this survey that has received the warmest reception among pundits on the Left, it is the section on “empathy.” Respondents were asked to agree or disagree on whether “Empathy is a foundational moral value that helps build a healthy society,” or whether “Empathy can become dangerous when it leads people away from building a society guided by God’s truth.” It found that 68% of Americans chose the former and 27% the latter. Among religious groups, only white evangelicals chose the latter (54%).
“Views that empathy is dangerous are positively correlated with holding Christian nationalist views.” This conclusion was not only predictable—PRRI has long cast white evangelicals as a threat to American freedoms—it was baked into the survey.
If someone says that peace is preferable to war, is he being inconsistent to say that there are times when war is the only realistic means to peace? Only an immature person, or one who is highly politicized, would say he is. The same is true of empathy.
Social psychologist Jane Adams writes that “Empathy is a quality we treasure in others because it makes us feel known and understood.” But she hastens to add, “There’s a dark side to empathy, seen in people who may set us up to be exploited, manipulated or conned out of something valuable.”
Yes, empathy is mostly a good attribute. But like any value, it is capable of being perverted. Therefore, to say empathy “can become dangerous” should be axiomatic. For example, showing empathy for jihadists can be downright dangerous—they should be shown disdain not empathy.
PRRI tries hard to portray traditionalists who believe in God as a force to be reckoned with, but they provide no evidence. The Democratic Socialists of America are a threat to our freedoms, not church-going Christians.
SOURCE Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights
CONTACT: 212-371-3191, pr@catholicleague.org
